October 13, 2026
A woman wrote in to an advice columnist saying that her family makes her and her husband feel guilty if they don’t spend Thanksgiving and Christmas with them. They live several hours closer to the wife’s family, but the husband resents having his family get less priority. In addition, his parents are older and he feels that their time with his parents is limited.
How, the writer asked, could they make a decision that is fair without spending every holiday without disappointing someone?
I expected the columnist to give a Carolyn Hax-type answer: You can’t. Your parents are master manipulators and you’re buying into it. It’s time for everyone to grow up—your parents should stop whining and you should act like the adults that you are and do what is best for you, whether it’s visiting his parents, your parents, or staying home. (My words; Carolyn might have been more tactful.)
Instead, the columnist suggested that they invite the husband’s parents to the wife’s parents’ gathering.
So, technically, she answered the question that was asked; but not the question that needed to be answered.
They should have asked Carolyn.